Artificial Intelligence or Authentic Creation? The Debate Over Copyrighting AI Art.

Artificial Intelligence or Authentic Creation? The Debate Over Copyrighting AI Art.

Is artificial intelligence (AI) created art, art?

In an age where technological innovation permeates every facet of our lives, the intersection of art and artificial intelligence presents a legal and ethical quagmire. The recent ruling by US District Court Judge Beryl A. Howell declaring AI-generated artwork ineligible for copyright has ignited heated debates among artists, tech enthusiasts, and legal experts.

  1. Artificial Intelligence as an Extension of the Creator

The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence has been nothing short of astounding, transitioning from an academic niche to a cornerstone of industries worldwide. But at its core, AI remains deeply human. As Dr. Fei-Fei Li eloquently highlighted in her New York Times article, “Despite its name, there is nothing ‘artificial’ about this technology — it is made by humans, intended to behave like humans and affects humans.”1 The very algorithms and data structures that empower these systems are a direct reflection of human intent and design.

As AI continues to shape our world, it is crucial to remember that it’s not an autonomous entity operating in isolation. It’s a tool, crafted by human hands, mirroring human values, and aiming to augment human capabilities.

  1. Consistency with Other Tools

Historically, artists have always utilized tools to aid their creative process. Whether it’s Leonardo da Vinci’s brush or a modern graphic designer’s Adobe Photoshop, tools have been instrumental in bringing artistic visions to life. If we accept digitally-edited photos as original works, why should AI-generated art be any different?

  1. Distinguishing Artificial Intelligence from Animals

Judge Howell’s reference to the “monkey selfie” case might be misleading for some. Animals act on instinct, whereas AI operates based on logic and instructions provided by humans. While a monkey might accidentally snap a selfie, AI creates art based on its human-derived programming.

  1. Rewarding Innovation

Denying copyright for AI-generated works could stifle innovation. As AI researcher Andrew Ng puts it, “Much of human progress was sparked by tools: The plow, the printing press, the computer.”2 By not recognizing the copyright of AI-generated work, we risk disincentivizing creators from pushing the boundaries of what’s possible.

  1. Complexity of AI Training

Training an AI model is no simple task. It requires expertise, curated datasets, and numerous decisions that influence the end result. For example, Google’s DeepDream, which transforms images in unique, often psychedelic ways, relies on layers of data and algorithmic choices made by its creators3. Each AI-generated piece is a testament to that labor and expertise.

  1. Economic Implications

In a world where AI-generated art lacks protection, the market could be inundated with freely available content, undermining the value of human-made artwork. This could have severe repercussions for artists trying to monetize their creations in a rapidly digitizing economy.

  1. Precedent for Derivative Works

The Copyright Act has provisions for derivative works, which, while based on existing creations, offer something new or transformative. Consider the case of “The Wind Done Gone,” a retelling of “Gone with the Wind” from a different character’s perspective. Though controversial, it was deemed transformative enough to warrant its own copyright4. AI-generated content, with its fresh perspectives, might deserve similar consideration.

  1. Subjectivity of “Human Touch”

Defining the “guiding human hand” is subjective. Take, for instance, an artist who uses AI to produce a hundred sketches, then manually selects and refines one. Doesn’t that process, that selection, embody the human touch?

As technology continues to evolve, it’s essential for our legal systems to adapt and address the unique challenges posed by innovations like AI. The debate over copyrighting AI art isn’t just about legal technicalities; it’s a reflection of our changing relationship with technology and creativity in the 21st century.

Stephen Hawking once warned, “We stand on the threshold of a brave new world. It is an exciting, if precarious, place to be and we benefit from it.”5 As we continue to grapple with these complex issues, it’s crucial to approach them with an open mind and a willingness to adapt.

Sources:

Footnotes

  1. Li, Fei-Fei. “Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence.” Stanford HAI, 2018.
  2. Ng, Andrew. “The State of Artificial Intelligence.” TEDxBrussels, 2017.
  3. Mordvintsev, Alexander, et al. “DeepDream – a code example for visualizing Neural Networks.” Google AI Blog, 2015.
  4. “Suntrust v. Houghton Mifflin Co.” United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit, 2001.
  5. Hawking, Stephen. “Brief Answers to the Big Questions.” John Murray, 2018.

 

Curtesy of Alan Olsen’s

Sponsored by:

Posted in

Accounting Joke Videos

Accounting Joke Videos Insanity So, you’re saying it’s ok. Insanity, is a side-effect of tax law. Accounting Classes I tried taking a course on ethics for my CPE credits, but everything contradicted what I learned in my accounting classes. Feelings So, you’re saying that I should own my feelings… but my accountant said that it…

Series LLC: Simplify Your Legal Entity Structure

Series LLC: Simplify Your Legal Entity Structure

Series LLC: Simplify Your Legal Entity Structure By Ron Cohen, CPA, MST Partner Greenstein, Rogoff, Olsen & Co., LLP Many businesses are being set up as a Series LLC where multiple projects are involved. Rather than setting up an entirely new Limited Liability Company (LLC) for each project, a Series LLC can be formed, with…

family home

Transferring the Family Home to Your Children

Transferring the Family Home to Your Children An estate and tax planning specialist mentioned to us recently that one of the most common arguments among siblings is over the fate of the family home after the death of a parent. For both sentimental as well as financial reasons, the transfer of a residence can be…

best accounting jokes

Best Accounting Jokes

Best Accounting Jokes One-liners Definitions of Accountants Newton’s Laws of Accounting Top 10 Signs Your Accountant is Nuts Top 10 Signs You’ve Hired a Bad Accountant Top 10 Pick-Up Lines of Accountants Top 10 Ways To Make Doing Your Taxes More Fun Top 10 Signs You Work in Public Accounting/Consulting You Might Be An Accountant…